MeatJournal.com 1.1: From the Listservs

ASLE (Association for the Study of Literature and Environment)

by John Garcia

MeatJournal.com readers who would like to catch up on recent ASLE listserv happenings might ponder the following question: Which mustachioed mainstream news personality links such sundry topics as the tragic SE Asia tsunami, Rachel Carson, malaria, and DDT? ASLE list members concur that ABC newsman John Stossel is a "good looking" corporate shill who regularly launches "snide and ill-informed attacks on environmentalists." That's right, 2005 will surely be remembered as the year where fair and balanced reporting had hit such lows so as to drag the bedraggled corpse of one Rachel Carson kicking and screaming from the grave (we should note here that Carson passed away in 1964!). It seems that media pundits like Stossel and Thomas Sowell (arch-conservative, op-ed shill from the Hoover Institute) just can't get over their love affair with DDT and are blaming Carson for the deaths of untold thousands of malaria tied to the widespread disuse of the pesticide.

ASLE folks aren't taking this torching of the author of Silent Spring lightly. In fact, this reframing of "public opinion of Carson" makes sense as part of a broad assault on environmental issues from the Bush administration. Look for a rough next four years for environmental policy, starting possibly with Bush's "repairs" to the supposedly "broken" Endangered Species Act. The good people at ASLE have a message to all of you on the home front: Keep your powder dry. There's trouble brewing.

ASLE's critique of the televised media's response to the SE Asian tsunami, with all the prominently displayed loss of human life, has been equally severe. The conspicuous lack of similar images from the war front in Iraq strikes many ASLE regulars as odd. One poster asks, "Is this death pornography acceptable because [the disaster] is 'natural'?" It is discomforting indeed that much of the human interest directed from this major catastrophe is because of the high ratio of Western tourists to poor unfortunate indigenous peoples. Analyzing the media representation of the tsunami, some at ASLE see it as "an editorial decision to determine how to 'market' death." But life goes on and tourism in the area is on the rebound. One white woman photographed while vacationing amidst the suffering strikes an ASLE poster as a "portrait of colonial indifference." Powerful stories of resistance have also surfaced: one indigenous tribesman whipped out his bow and arrow to shoot at a US military helicopter attempting to deliver "aid" to his tribe. Being that his tribe had resisted outside intrusion since Paleolithic times, we might take this as his way of politely saying no to corporate welfare.

[Editor's note: as to be expected when commenting on listservs, the above report is admittedly behind the times. Readers interested in all things ecocritical are suggested to subscribe to the ASLE list].

MEATJOURNAL.COM || ISSN 1549-4454 || VOL 1.1 (Spring 2005)
Editorial Information || Comments?

Buy a MeatJournal.com t-shirt. Volume 1.1 profits will all be sent to The Amanda Foundation.